The headgear without a doubt, if it is double and / or double strap, the better. I'm not a huge fan of expanders, but if I need them, I won't turn them down. Time wise, I would love to connect or at least 20 hours, but realistically 12 hours would be what would work for me.

It's a great question, and one I'd need to sit down and think about, but I think Herbst would win.  in real life - as opposed to fetish fantasies - a headgear gets really old really fast.  So I'd take the Herbst

Yeah, I agree with you. In real life the Herbst wins. I just couldn't see myself getting away with headgear in my real life. Plus, I've always wanted to try a Herbst.

In a pure fantasy world though? Definitely headgear (combination high-pull/cervical, both with safety straps).

Combination hg. It's always been my dream.

Although some of those custom interlandi catch my eye on occasion.



Although a Herbst 1, with no lateral movement would be exciting haha

I have always wanted to try a Type 1 or 2 herbst. but I would probably say headgear, especially since I'm class iii

I'd like both for fun! Herbst with double expanders seems fun. I prefer braces on others (I think?), but I do like the idea of having them. Especially as a couple!

Now that I am wearing braces again, I also have to wear a headgear again 16 hours a day.

Definitely headgear for me.