That's a bit of a longer chapter, but I don't want to split it.
Chapter 18/22 - The truth
They walk side by side in silence again. In the distance a car drives by; behind a window, the TV is flickering, but otherwise it's quiet.
But it is exactly this silence, that starts to weigh on her nerves. And finally, Leonie feels like she has to say something. The longer they walk side-by-side in silence, the more restless she becomes. Until she can stand it no longer: "You know, dad, I'm a little scared of the next orthodontist."
"Why's that?"
"Well, because I haven't been to a doctor in such a long time. Half a year... long enough that even the health insurance is contacting us! I'm afraid he'll give me a hard time about it!"
"I don't think he's going to chastise you. Sure, he will ask you why you took such a long break. You'll have to expect that, but that's about it. While we're at it: Would you tell me WHY this pause has become so long?"
"Because...", Leonie hesitates, "...because Dr. Reinhard was a stupid git. That really put me off for a while!"
He looks at his daughter in the light of a streetlamp. "I can understand that. But somehow, I have a feeling that's not all. Won't you tell me?"
But his daughter does not answer. She is busy blowing white clouds into the air.
"You know that you can tell me everything, Leonie? If you want to tell me something, then I'll be there for you, no matter what it's about."
"I know, I know," but there is still no answer.
"Does it have something to do with you liking braces?"
His daughter stops dead in her tracks. She looks at him wide-eyed and scared. Then she looks down, ashamed, "You think I'm mad!?"
He shakes his head. "Where did you get that stupid idea?"
She just shrugs her shoulders.
"I'll tell you something, child. But be so kind and listen to me first, OK?"
Leonie nods uncertainly. So, there it is! The conversation he didn't want to have with her in the living room at home. The reproaches, the moral sermon, the I-am-so-disappointed-by-you. She clenches her hands into fists. "It's so embarrassing...", directed at no one in particular. Especially not at her father, whom she takes great pain to ignore.
And yet - of course - he heard. "This conversation isn't easy for either of us, child," is his gentle reply. "But I think it's high time we addressed this issue, don't you think so too?"
A silent shrug is all he gets from his daughter.
"It's not going to get any easier if we ignore it any longer. You don't need to answer now; neither 'yes' nor 'no' nor anything else, Leonie. Just listen to me and then think about it, OK?"
Even though she nods, it is clear that Leonie would give a lot to be able to escape this conversation.
"So... You have a 'preference' for braces. Many people have some kind of 'preference'." He smiles: "Can you still remember your Uncle Robert? And how he had always enjoyed riding his motorcycles?"
Leonie nods cautiously. She has no idea what her father is getting at.
He continues: "You could say that he had a preference for motorcycling."
Leonie looks at her father as if he's gone mad. "That's something COMPLETELY different!", she murmurs nearly inaudible.
"Granted, not every 'preference' is the same. With Robert it was an intensely pursued hobby," he nods. "Nevertheless: He had a lot of fun riding his motorcycles. And you... You have fun wearing your braces."
Leonie looks away.
"Are you ashamed, child?"
Leonie nods silently.
"Why? Tell me: Did you feel embarrassed listening to Robert talk about his motorcycle rides?"
Leonie shakes her head: "Why should I? It was really interesting. If I had been old enough back then, I might even have made my motorcycle license because of it. Uncle Robert was always good at telling stories."
"Why are you embarrassed about one and not the other?" he asks her. "Where's the difference?"
At first Leonie doesn't answer. Then, with little more than a whisper: "This braces-thing... that's not normal!"
"Says who, child?"
His daughter doesn't answer.
"What do you think: Maybe the difference is that society accepts motorcycling as a hobby? And that braces are seen more as a necessary evil. A lot of people might therefore have a hard time understanding how something like that can be fun?"
Leonie's ears are burning. If they had been at home in their apartment, she probably would now have fled to her room. But she can't just run away here. Maybe that's why her father has insisted on taking this stroll? Because he wanted to make sure that she doesn't abscond halfway through?
"Would you agree with me when I say: The main difference between a 'harmless hobby' and 'unnatural behavior' is whether society accepts what you do?"
His daughter nods. And her lips become even thinner.
"In other words: Whether you are 'crazy' always depends on the point of view of the person who makes this 'diagnosis'. Some would say that you're quite normal. Others would call you quirky. Still others would say that you're indeed a nutcase." He pauses for effect: "And the expert would probably call it a fetish!"
Leonie shakes her head, ashamed of herself. However, the father continues: "Yes, Leonie, I think we may as well call it that." With a gentle smile, he looks down at his daughter, who is standing next to him:
Hands in her coat pockets, head turned to one side. She doesn't want to look at her father now. A few seconds pass.
"You disagree?" he then asks.
Her reply consists of a mixture of a nod, a shake of the head and a shrug.
"Even if we do call your relationship with braces a 'fetish', you don't need to take that to heart. Because having a fetish isn't a bad thing."
Leonie snorts through clenched teeth, a white cloud rises to the sky.
"Yes, I certainly mean that," affirms the father, "A fetish is nothing bad, even if people are made to believe that all the time!" He wants to put an arm around his daughter's shoulders, but she flinches. The father feels a little helpless; he hadn't expected that and now he doesn't know, what to do.
"A lot of people have some sort of 'preference'. Many of those are accepted by society as 'harmless hobbies'. But if not... Then it doesn't matter whether you call it [ i]'sexual preference'[/i], 'extravagance', 'kink' or 'fetish' or something else. Most people have a hard time admitting that they have SUCH a preference. Precisely because the subject is so extremely stigmatized."
"'Stig...' what?" Leonie blurts out before she can stop herself.
"'Stigmatized': Laden with prejudices," explains the father. "Mostly with false prejudices. A fetish really is nothing bad, child, you can believe me."
"Then why is it so 'stigma...' You know what I mean? Why?"
The father sighs: "People are dumb, Leonie. They're afraid of things they don't understand. And people without a fetish find it difficult to understand what drives people with such preferences. And because they can't understand it, they are afraid of it. They demonize it. And that - of course - makes it extremely difficult for people with fetishes to admit that they have something that others consider 'deviant' and 'perverted'."
Leonie presses her lips together.
"If people would just be open and honest with each other, everyone would realize that the 'others' are just normal people as well. People just like you and me."
Leonie shakes her head.
"Do you not want to believe me, child? Or can you not?"
Now the girl laughs: "Oh, dad, I want to believe you, I really do! I just have a hard time with the 'just normal people' part!"
"Oh child, don't you think the earth would be a damn bleak place if everyone was 'perfectly normal'?"
"Right now, I'm wishing for it..."
"Then you may as well stop wishing for that again now."
Then he adds: "However, if I may say so: Of course, not everyone has a soft spot for braces like you do."
Leonie rolls her eyes.
"There are 'other topics' that are much more well-known and 'popular': Foot fetish. Latex-and-leather. Bondage. S/M. Just to name a few."
Leonie's eyes widen as she hears what her father is saying.
"Are you embarrassed, child?" he asks softly.
"Of course! I... I NEVER expected that we would talk about something like THAT!"
"You have problems with people who have a fetish?"
"No, I don't." She shakes her head hastily, "What you mentioned before: Bondage and all that stuff..." She shrugs: "That's not my cup of tea, but if someone likes it: »More power to them...«"
For a short moment, she smiles broadly: "On the other hand: A pretty girl in tight leather pants: Yes, I'd definitely like that..."
He nods: "You came out to me last year that you like girls. Would you tell me: Are you ashamed of not being straight?"
Slowly Leonie shakes her head: "I'm surely not going to tell every soul on this planet. There are still enough as**oles around that cannot accept that. But no... I'm not ashamed of that. Not anymore at least. I came to accept it."
He smiles: "Do you realize, what you just said? You called those people who cannot accept your life-choices »as**oles«. As in: »It's those people - and not ME - who have to change their views!« But when it comes to your fetish, you want to hide under a rock..."
Leonie looks to the side: "That's different!"
"Is it really? Sure: Being gay isn't the same as having a fetish, I give you that. You really must not say that those are the same! On the other hand: The LGBT-people had - and still HAVE - to fight, not to be regarded as 'deviant'. Just as people with fetishes have to! Over the past decades however, society slowly changed. 'Being gay' is now in the process of being accepted by society, but still there is backlash."
"If you look at it from this side, child: Having a fetish and not-being-hetero were once both regarded as 'deviant'. One of them is finally more-or-less accepted. Don't you think that this shines a ray of hope on the fact, that the other will become more acceptable over time as well?"
His daughter doesn't answer at once. "Maybe... but other people still HAVE a problem with fetishes. Dad, you said that yourself just now. What do I know: Maybe it will change in thirty or fifty years. But that doesn't help me NOW!"
"Doesn't that make you think that maybe having a fetish - just like being gay - is nothing to be ashamed of?", he asks.
Leonie shakes her head. "I know, what you're trying to say. I just... I just can't...", she shrugs her shoulders. "I'm not allowed to judge!"
"Of course you're allowed," he contradicts. "You are just as much a part of this society as anyone else. You may judge others just as they judge you."
"Yes, but..."
He smiles: "I have the feeling that your views on that matter are significantly more open than many others."
"It's THEIR life and not mine. They should do what makes them happy. No, I don't have a problem with other people being gay or trans or whatever. Or with them having a fetish. Really not." And then much quieter: "I have a problem with ME having one!"
"But if you give other people permission to be happy in their own way, why do you not allow that yourself?"
Leonie shrugs. She does not find an answer to this question. "I haven't thought about that yet," she has to admit. But at the same time, it's clear that she still has trouble accepting that she's 'different'.
"I've already told you that you don't have to be ashamed. That there's nothing bad about it and that everything is frowned upon because people are too stupid to understand it."
"It's easy for you to say, dad!" Leonie exclaims. "You have no idea what..." She breaks off.
"Tell me, child: why don't you have a problem if other people have a fetish, but you can't accept it for yourself?"
Leonie does not answer.
"Uncle Robert drove his motorcycle nearly everywhere. He had four of five of them. He even repaired and modded them himself. He was more involved in his hobby than many other people. So much so that some people looked at him askance."
Her favorite uncle being criticized makes Leonie start in anger: "So what? What's so bad about driving motorcycles? Nothing at all!"
"What's so bad about wearing braces and enjoying the experience?", her father asks softly.
Leonie looks at him with wide-open eyes. She doesn't find an answer. "Why... why are you trying so hard to convince me that..." she shrugs: "... that I... don't have a 'problem'?"
"Because you don't. And because I think that it would be stupid if you beat yourself up over something that doesn't warrant that."
A few seconds pass. Then a few more. Leonie just looks straight ahead.
"We don't have to find the answer to every single question here-and-now," he partially closes the topic. "Just think about it, child!"
For a few seconds, they stand side by side in silence. Leonie blushes and turns her head even further away, "You seem to know exactly what I... what I feel and..." She licks her lips. "You know: What... What 'makes me tick'!"
"I can guess," is his soft reply.
"That's so embarrassing!" in barely more than a whisper.
"I'm not Wikipedia, you can look up everything there much better than I could ever explain it to you. Now let me just say two things:"
He reaches out for his daughter. This time, Leonie allows him to take her into his arms. Then he bends his knees a little so that he can look his daughter directly in the eyes. Leonie sinks her hands - trembling with cold and nervousness - even deeper into her coat pockets.
She no longer manages to escape his eyes. Now... here it comes. What... What is her father going to say? Is it going to be very bad? She presses her lips together.
"»A fetish is nothing bad« and »I don't judge you«. You are my daughter and I love you with all my heart. Just the way you are!"
Leonie sniffs, but not because of the cold. She blinks several times.
A few seconds pass during which both stand silently next to each other.
"Let's go on, I'm really getting cold," she finally asks. Her father surely expected a different answer, but he straightens up again.
A short time later, walking silently side-by-side - they turn into 'their' alley; they will soon be back at their apartment.
"You are stupid. Like really really stupid!" Leonie complains at last.
"Why, child? What have I done now?"
"It's your fault that my eyes are frozen shut now!" the girl wipes the tears from her eyes.
"I don't think so: tears are salty and salt water has a lower freezing point!" He replies dryly.
In response, Leonie prods her father's side.
Comment: Yes, I know: Directly comparing hobbies and sexual preferences probably isn't correct from a psychological standpoint. But if it helps Leonie...
And yes: Kink and fetish are not the same. And BDSM is not a fetish, but both are paraphilias. Which again is a subpart of sexual preferences…
But I think, that this is neither the right time nor the right place to further discuss that.